The Sneaky Reason You’re Gaining Weight (Even When You Eat ‘Healthy’ Out)

You’ve been putting in the effort — tracking your meals, making healthier choices, and staying consistent. So why does the scale feel like it’s mocking you? What is the real reason you're gaining weight?

One common but often overlooked reason: eating out.

Even when you think you’re making good choices — grilled chicken, a fresh salad, a lean steak — restaurants have a way of loading up meals with extra calories in ways that are easy to miss. If you’re not accounting for them, they could be the silent culprit stalling your progress.

Let’s break down where those hidden calories come from — and why overestimating your calories when eating out is the smartest move.

1. Cooking Oils & Butters You Can’t See

• That “grilled chicken” or “pan-seared salmon” might sound clean, but behind the scenes, chefs are often using generous amounts of oil or butter to enhance flavour and texture.

• A steak could be basted in butter mid-cook — that’s an easy 200–300 extra calories.

• Vegetables? Often sautéed in oil, not steamed.

• Eggs or omelettes? Usually cooked in more fat than you’d ever use at home.

• Even if it’s not listed on the menu, assume most dishes include added fats — and track accordingly.

2. Dressings, Sauces & Glazes (AKA Flavour Bombs in Disguise)

• Think your salad is a low-calorie win? Not if it’s drenched in creamy dressing or topped with candied nuts, cheese, and croutons. One serving of Caesar dressing can be 250–300 calories — and restaurants rarely stop at one serving.

• Glazes and sauces (like teriyaki, honey mustard, or balsamic reductions) are often packed with sugar and oil.

• Even “light” vinaigrettes can be calorie-dense due to high oil content.

Pro tip: Ask for sauces and dressings on the side and use less than half. Better yet, bring your own or skip them altogether.

3. Fried Food Adds Up Fast

Even if it’s just the chips on the side, fried foods are calorie sponges. That golden crunch comes from being submerged in oil — often reused multiple times.

• A medium portion of fries: 400–500 calories.

• A fried chicken breast vs grilled: +300 calories, easily.

• Tempura, spring rolls, breaded anything — same story.

A dish that looks modest on the plate can end up pushing your total calories far higher than expected.

4. Massive Portion Sizes You Don’t Question

Restaurants serve big plates because it looks generous — and you’re more likely to feel like you're getting value for money. But those plates often hold double or triple the portion size you'd eat at home.

• Pasta dishes can clock in at 1,000+ calories even without creamy sauce.

• A “single” wrap or sandwich might contain two full servings of meat, cheese, and sauce.

• Rice, beans, chips, bread — the portions add up before you even get to dessert.

You might not feel overly full — because it’s engineered that way.

5. Drinks and Extras You Forget to Count

It’s not just the food. Drinks and extras often go untracked and unnoticed:

• A glass of wine = 120–150 calories

• A pint of beer = 200+

• A cocktail = 300–500, especially with sugary mixers

• That free bread or second latte = more sneaky calories

  
  

These can quietly double the calorie total of your meal.

6. Desserts: One More Bite Can Blow the Budget

You might “share” dessert or just have a few spoonfuls, but don’t underestimate how calorie-packed these treats can be.

• Cheesecake? 500–1,000 calories per slice.

• Chocolate lava cake? Easily 600+

• Even a fruit-based dessert (with added syrup, crumble or cream) can tip the scales.

They’re delicious, but unless you’re adjusting calories elsewhere in your day or week, that final bite might be more than your plan accounted for.

So What Can You Do?

Here’s how to stay in control — without giving up your social life:

• Overestimate: If the meal seems “clean,” still add 200–300 calories when tracking — especially for protein-based dishes that were likely cooked with added fat.

• Ask Questions: Don’t be shy — ask how things are cooked or if anything is added.

• Choose Smart: Go grilled, baked or steamed where possible (if its not obvious, request it); skip or minimise dressings, sauces, and deep-fried sides.

• Split or Save: Share dishes, or box up half before you start eating.

• Track Honestly: It’s better to overshoot slightly than pretend that restaurant salad was only 400 calories.

Final Thought

You don’t need to avoid restaurants altogether — just be more aware. Eating out is about more than just food; it's social, enjoyable, and part of life. But if you're hitting your macros all week and not seeing results, those sneaky extras might be the missing piece.

Overestimate, stay mindful, and enjoy — without the mystery weight gain.

With our clients, we look at all social occasions in advance and plan around them, so meals out and celebrations can be enjoyed without guilt or guesswork. If you’d like help doing the same, feel free to get in touch by clicking below and filling in the form.

Contact Jamie